Our favorite self-appointed crime solvers are back on the beat in Only Murders in the Building Season 2 — only now, they’re also prime suspects in the Hulu series’ central investigation?

At the end of Season 1, Charles, Oliver and Mabel were taken into custody for the murder of Arconia board president Bunny Folger?

And in Season 2, the amateur sleuths are on a race to unmask Bunny’s killer, during which a number of unfortunate complications arise: Not only have they been publicly implicated, but they’re now the subjects of a competing podcast, Only Murderers in the Building?

Additionally, there are two side mysteries to solve: Who texted Charles and Oliver to get out of the building the night of Bunny’s murder.